The Ollie Barney Memorial Award is presented annually to the member who makes the greatest impact in matches throughout the season of play. Ollie Barney was an Original Twilighter member.
| 2008 Kenny Matsuo | 2009 Steve Wiles | 2010 Bill McCrae | 2011 Jeff Lorz |
| 2012 Garry Henry | 2013 Steve Bal | 2014 Anthony Atherton | 2015 Kenny Matsuo |
| 2016 ~ | 2017 Kenny Matsuo | 2018 Trevon Johnston | 2019 Trevor Johnston |
| 2020 ~ | 2021 ~ | 2022 Erich Falkenhagem | 2023 Trevor Johnston |
| 2024 Ted Matsumoto | 2025 Doug Embury | 2026 Jake Sol | |